WV Supreme Court issues decision in Aracoma widows suit - WBOY.com: Clarksburg, Morgantown: News, Sports, Weather

WV Supreme Court issues decision in Aracoma widows suit

Posted: Updated:
  • Local NewsMore>>

  • Vintage Restaurant and Wine Bar Opens Its Doors To The Public

    Vintage Restaurant and Wine Bar Opens Its Doors To The Public

    Thursday, April 17 2014 12:08 AM EDT2014-04-17 04:08:19 GMT
    On Wednesday, people in Randolph County welcomed a new business to the community.  The Vintage Restaurant and Wine Bar is located on Randolph Avenue, in Elkins.  The menu offers new modern American food
    On Wednesday, people in Randolph County welcomed a new business to the community.  The Vintage Restaurant and Wine Bar is located on Randolph Avenue, in Elkins.  The menu offers new modern American food
  • WVU Public Relation Student's Help A Local Non-Profit

    WVU Public Relation Student's Help A Local Non-Profit

    Wednesday, April 16 2014 11:50 PM EDT2014-04-17 03:50:05 GMT
    The Nine students working on this project for their public relations campaigns course, have completely re-branded the non-profit, by creating a sufficient mission statement, new name, and social media
    The Nine students working on this project for their public relations campaigns course, have completely re-branded the non-profit, by creating a sufficient mission statement, new name, and social media
  • Morgantown Battles Underage and High Risk Drinking

    Morgantown Battles Underage and High Risk Drinking

    Wednesday, April 16 2014 11:47 PM EDT2014-04-17 03:47:11 GMT
    WVU and the City of Morgantown, paired up to host a discussion April 16 on underage and high risk drinking. The discussion was meant to discuss the problems at hand, and talk about possible solutions.
    WVU and the City of Morgantown, paired up to host a discussion April 16 on underage and high risk drinking. The discussion was meant to discuss the problems at hand, and talk about possible solutions.

The West Virginia Supreme Court recently issued a decision in a case filed by two widows following the deaths of two miners in the Aracoma mine fire, allowing the widows to proceed with their suit against the government.

The 4th Circuit Court of Appeals certified the question to West Virginia's highest court asking "whether a private party conducting inspections of a mine and mine operator for compliance with mine safety regulations is liable for the wrongful death of a miner resulting from the private party's negligent inspection."

The negligence and wrongful death suit was filed in April 28, 2010, by Delorice Bragg on behalf of her deceased husband, Don Israel Bragg, and Freda Hatfield on behalf of the estate of Ellery Hatfield against the United States.

According to court documents, Aracoma Coal and several supervisors at the mine pleaded guilty to federal charges of criminal negligence.

The company also settled separate allegations brought against it by the same two widows in this suit, court documents state. 

In their federal lawsuit, Bragg and Hatfield asserted the Mine Safety and Health Administration was negligent in its safety inspection of the Aracoma Coal Co.'s Alma Mine. That negligence, they allege, resulted in the death of the two mine roof bolters.  

According to the 4th Circuit's July 17 unpublished per curiam opinion, the federal court dismissed the suit because of the determination that West Virginia law would not hold a private analogue to the MSHA inspectors liable for negligence.    

In their Feb. 5 opinion, justices concluded that a "private party conducting inspections of a mine and mine operator for compliance with mine safety regulations is liable for the wrongful death of a miner resulting from the private party's negligent inspection."

"A private inspector who inspects a work premises for the purpose of furthering the safety of employees who work on said premises owes a duty of care to those employees to conduct inspections with ordinary skill, care and diligence commensurate with that rendered by members of his or her profession," Justice Robin Davis wrote in the decision.