Patriot's rejecting its union contract was legal but wrong - WBOY.com: Clarksburg, Morgantown: News, Sports, Weather

Patriot's rejecting its union contract was legal but wrong

Posted: Updated:
  • OPINIONState Journal EditorialsMore>>

  • Wider lens necessary for effective education

    Wider lens necessary for effective education

    Friday, July 25 2014 6:00 AM EDT2014-07-25 10:00:24 GMT
    We say it often, but if West Virginia is going to reach its enormous potential, we will need a dynamic, robust educational system that challenges and prepares our people for the rigors of life in the 21st century.
    We say it often, but if West Virginia is going to reach its enormous potential, we will need a dynamic, robust educational system that challenges and prepares our people for the rigors of life in the 21st century.
  • Can we be realistic on roads?

    Can we be realistic on roads?

    Friday, July 18 2014 7:00 AM EDT2014-07-18 11:00:54 GMT
    Building and maintaining roads should not be a political issue. In fact, it should be pretty straightforward. Potholes need filled, drainage ditches need cleaned, the highways need striped — while it might be painstaking and expensive, the overall concept is pretty simple.
    Building and maintaining roads should not be a political issue. In fact, it should be pretty straightforward. Potholes need filled, drainage ditches need cleaned, the highways need striped — while it might be painstaking and expensive, the overall concept is pretty simple.
  • Looking the other way perpetuates criminal politics

    Looking the other way perpetuates criminal politics

    Friday, July 11 2014 10:46 AM EDT2014-07-11 14:46:55 GMT
    Former Mingo County Prosecutor Michael Sparks has been sentenced to 12 months in prison for his role in a political scheme that has dominated headlines for nearly a year and shined a bright light on one part of the state’s tangled web of public corruption.
    Former Mingo County Prosecutor Michael Sparks has been sentenced to 12 months in prison for his role in a political scheme that has dominated headlines for nearly a year and shined a bright light on one part of the state’s tangled web of public corruption.

A promise is a promise. While a federal court judge recently ruled Patriot Coal has the authority to reject its collective bargaining agreement and modify retiree benefits, we think this sets a bad precedent.

Patriot Coal was formed as a spinoff of Peabody Energy. Patriot declared bankruptcy, claiming it could no longer afford $1.6 billion worker and retiree commitments. By wiping out Patriot's pension and health benefits, an estimated 10,000 retired West Virginia and Kentucky miners, plus 13,000 dependents, have been hit. The United Mine Workers of America alleged that the company did so to intentionally escape contracts negotiated with workers, but the judge sided with the company.

It's possible the union's requests were too much, but that is immaterial. The company agreed to its demands and should have lived up to its end of the deal. Those contracts were signed in good faith. Patriot's financial problems are lamentable; however, the company said it was going to do something and it should have done it.

This case is likely not over. We hope everyone can get back to the bargaining table and hammer out a compromise everyone can live with and both sides can uphold.