Patriot's rejecting its union contract was legal but wrong - WBOY.com: Clarksburg, Morgantown: News, Sports, Weather

Patriot's rejecting its union contract was legal but wrong

Posted: Updated:
  • Local NewsMore>>

  • WVU Nursing Work to Educate Christian Help Clients on Healthy Eating

    WVU Nursing Work to Educate Christian Help Clients on Healthy Eating

    Thursday, April 17 2014 9:43 AM EDT2014-04-17 13:43:59 GMT
    Eating healthy on a tight budget doesn't have to be a struggle. WVU Nursing students have been teaching Christian Help clients how to eat healthy using items found in Christian Help's food pantry. Students
    Eating healthy on a tight budget doesn't have to be a struggle. WVU Nursing students have been teaching Christian Help clients how to eat healthy using items found in Christian Help's food pantry. Students
  • North Central WV Weekend Outlook for April 18-20

    North Central WV Weekend Outlook for April 18-20

    Thursday, April 17 2014 9:36 AM EDT2014-04-17 13:36:44 GMT
    With it being a holiday weekend, there's not much in the way of fairs or festivals scheduled, but there's still plenty to do around north central West Virginia. Saturday: Stonewall Resort, in Lewis County,
    With it being a holiday weekend, there's not much in the way of fairs or festivals scheduled, but there's still plenty to do around north central West Virginia. Saturday: Stonewall Resort, in Lewis County,
  • Vintage Restaurant and Wine Bar Opens Its Doors To The Public

    Vintage Restaurant and Wine Bar Opens Its Doors To The Public

    Thursday, April 17 2014 12:08 AM EDT2014-04-17 04:08:19 GMT
    On Wednesday, people in Randolph County welcomed a new business to the community.  The Vintage Restaurant and Wine Bar is located on Randolph Avenue, in Elkins.  The menu offers new modern American food
    On Wednesday, people in Randolph County welcomed a new business to the community.  The Vintage Restaurant and Wine Bar is located on Randolph Avenue, in Elkins.  The menu offers new modern American food
  • OPINIONState Journal EditorialsMore>>

  • Culture of corruption often fueled by weak economy

    Culture of corruption often fueled by weak economy

    Friday, April 11 2014 2:32 PM EDT2014-04-11 18:32:15 GMT
    West Virginia is burdened by a sad tradition of political corruption and graft.
    West Virginia is burdened by a sad tradition of political corruption and graft.
  • Only real change brings lasting prosperity

    Only real change brings lasting prosperity

    Friday, April 4 2014 6:00 AM EDT2014-04-04 10:00:15 GMT
    West Virginia's continual exploration and development of natural gas is the gateway to something better.
    West Virginia's continual exploration and development of natural gas is the gateway to something better.
  • Supreme Court inaction should spur in-state action

    Supreme Court inaction should spur in-state action

    Friday, March 28 2014 11:16 AM EDT2014-03-28 15:16:18 GMT
    The U.S. Supreme Court announced this week it will not review a case involving the Arch CoalSpruce No. 1 mountaintop removal mine.
    The U.S. Supreme Court announced this week it will not review a case involving the Arch CoalSpruce No. 1 mountaintop removal mine.

A promise is a promise. While a federal court judge recently ruled Patriot Coal has the authority to reject its collective bargaining agreement and modify retiree benefits, we think this sets a bad precedent.

Patriot Coal was formed as a spinoff of Peabody Energy. Patriot declared bankruptcy, claiming it could no longer afford $1.6 billion worker and retiree commitments. By wiping out Patriot's pension and health benefits, an estimated 10,000 retired West Virginia and Kentucky miners, plus 13,000 dependents, have been hit. The United Mine Workers of America alleged that the company did so to intentionally escape contracts negotiated with workers, but the judge sided with the company.

It's possible the union's requests were too much, but that is immaterial. The company agreed to its demands and should have lived up to its end of the deal. Those contracts were signed in good faith. Patriot's financial problems are lamentable; however, the company said it was going to do something and it should have done it.

This case is likely not over. We hope everyone can get back to the bargaining table and hammer out a compromise everyone can live with and both sides can uphold.